Peer Review Sheet for How Writing Works, Chapter 3: Writing New Genres
Genre: Response Essay
|
|
Questions
|
Comments
|
Tasks
|
|
Genre, Audience, and Purpose
|
Does the document suit the genre of
a response essay?
Does it suit the audience?
Does
it meet the purpose of a response essay?
|
|
With an asterisk (*), mark one
place on the draft where the writer seems to stray from the genre of the
response essay (say, by offering too much personal opinion without evidence)
|
|
Design, Organization, Content, and
Style
|
Does the response essay include examples from the original
text? Does the writer provide a clear,
interesting thesis?
Is the style appropriate for a response essay?
Has the writer
proofread and edited carefully to avoid grammar and mechanical errors?
|
|
Underline at least one place on the draft where the writer
could provide more details (either from the text, or from personal
experience) to support the thesis.
|
|
Revision Plan:
|
For
the writer: What four things will you do when you revise this draft?
1)
2)
3)
4)
|
||
|
|
Reviewer’s name:
|
Writer’s name:
|
Date of Workshop:
|
